Sy's New York Pizza Menu

Introducing the Menu at Sy's New York Pizza

Sy's New York Pizza, nestled in Eugene, OR, offers a flavorful take on classic New York-style pizza with a focus on thin, crispy crusts and generous toppings. The menu highlights include the iconic NY Style Cheese Slice and creative options like the extra cheese and Italian sausage slice, alongside fan favorites such as the Half Sausage Half Pepperoni Pizza and the intriguing Einstein Slice. The standout Cacio e Pepe slice delivers a bold, spicy kick with no sauce, showcasing a delightful balance of cheese and crust crunch that truly impresses. For those craving something hearty, the Sicilian Cheese and Deep Dish Meat pizzas satisfy with dense, flavorful bites. Not to miss are the fresh garlic knots, a perfect side to complement any slice. Sy’s atmosphere, friendly staff, and massive portions make it not just a meal, but a genuine New York pizza experience in the heart of Oregon. This place truly honors tradition while inviting subtle innovation, delivering satisfying, lovingly crafted pies every time.

Pizza By The Slice

Neopolitan

$4.20

White

$4.20

Sicilian

$4.50

Add Toppings

$0.75

Large Neopolitan

$25.00

Large White

$25.00

Large Sicilian

$30.00

Add Toppings

$2.50

Medium Neopolitan

$20.00

Medium White

$20.00

Medium Sicilian

$25.00

Small Neopolitan

$15.00

Small White

$15.00

Small Sicilian

$17.00

Whole Pies

Sides

Garlic Knot

$0.75

6 Garlic Knots

$4.00

12 Garlic Knots

$6.00

Ranch

$0.75

Pizza Sauce

$0.75

Luigi's Italian Ice

$2.25

Fountain Soda

$2.50

Soda Can

$2.25

Bottled Water

$1.50

Vitamin Water

$2.50

Peak Unsweetened Iced Tea

$2.50

Peak Sweet Tea

$2.50

Beverages